Otterman speaks…

…about macs, web2.0, cats, cycling, teaching, natural history and life in Singapore.

Scheduling site – Doodle still rules the nest

Posted by otterman on 22 August 2008

When is Good

Kevin Lim highlighted a new scheduling website this morning: whenisgood.net.

I took it for a spin to compare it to Doodle and found that whenisgood

  • Does not need registration – same as doodle
  • Email notification also same
  • The setup page for the Scheduler look messy – not good
  • But it is easier to setup with many hourly options (I usually limit to a few with some pre-made phone calls)
  • Attendees need to click to see choice highlighted – ok
  • Scheduler can unclick names (listed by least options) to see if there is a date match – useful for very large meetings – good
  • But I cannot see individual choices easily – bad

So I prefer doodle still:

  • I can eyeball everyone’s choice on list easily, make a phone call to have one person succumb to persuasion
  • I find it easier to setup!
  • I have an account that keeps track of schedules I posted.

Does whenisgood have a niche? It looks like it could be useful for use for very large meetings in an office used to very specifically timed meetings blocks. And for offering many, many choices for a large number of people to chose from.

I’ll keep it in mind for a future meeting though to see if that uncovers more.

3 Responses to “Scheduling site – Doodle still rules the nest”

  1. acroamatic said

    More observations:

    * Didn’t notice the 15, 30, 60, day interval buttons at the top initially
    * Graphical method of choosing a time (at 15 and 30) becomes a hindrance
    * 15 and 30 minute intervals are restricted to office hours? How to plan meetups after work? (Oh, under Options, I think.)
    * Save the code after creating?
    * User has to manually bookmark the respective URLs to check on status and edit the event
    * No email notification of new inputs

    Doodle still my choice too.

    Let me know how real world use turns out.

  2. Kevin said

    Nice one… man you’re fast. I need to brush up on my blogging speed. Should we still do a checklist (using Apple Keynote or Numbers) comparing the different scheduling webapps?

  3. Tom said

    I was introduced to scheduleonce.com. it has a similar concept to the too above, but I think it is easier to use. Doodle has too much screens to go through and whenisgood has a very complicated page to see the attendees replies.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>